Quick comparison
| Feature | Shake It On | Caffeine |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $9.99 one-time | Free |
| How it works | Mouse movement | System API toggle |
| Smart conditions | โ (12 conditions) | โ |
| Scheduling | โ (hours + days) | โ |
| Camera detection | โ | โ |
| Focus/DND detection | โ | โ |
| Battery awareness | โ | โ |
| Configurable intervals | โ (6 presets) | โ (always on) |
| Keeps remote sessions alive | โ | โ |
| Actively maintained | โ | โ (1.6.4, Apr 2026) |
| Snooze | โ | โ |
About Caffeine
Caffeine is one of the originals. Coffee cup icon in the menu bar. Click it, Mac stays awake. Click again, back to normal. That's the whole thing.
It dates back to 2006 and is still updated: version 1.6.4 came out in April 2026 with macOS Tahoe support. You can set a timeout or a default duration. A separate App Store app, Caffeinated ($3.99), is built on the same idea.
Where Shake It On wins
Caffeine's simplicity is also its limit. Its site lists no conditions, so it can't tell that you're on battery, in a video call, or that it's the middle of the night.
Shake It On handles all of that:
- Smart conditions: pauses for video calls, battery, Focus mode, specific foreground apps
- Scheduling: runs during work hours, off the rest
- Mouse movement: your Mac sees real input, keeps remote desktop alive
- Snooze: quick pause when you need one
The other big gap: Caffeine prevents sleep at the system level but doesn't create any actual user activity. Slack and Teams still see you as idle. Remote desktop sessions can still time out. Shake It On generates real mouse input that registers everywhere.